Criticism and reporting
Reviews must be grounded in the work under discussion: listening for music, viewing for film and direct engagement with the relevant material for books and art. A trailer, synopsis or press release is not a substitute for a full film review. News and factual context should link to reliable sources, preferably original announcements, creator statements, official catalogues and credited release information. Publicity claims are attributed rather than presented as independently established facts.
Reporting standards
We do not invent contributors, quotations, interviews, concert or festival attendance, screenings or first-hand experiences. Reported facts are distinguished from critical judgments, and source material is attributed.
Film reviews and spoilers
Film criticism distinguishes description from interpretation and checks credits, release dates and version details. Significant plot revelations should carry a clear spoiler warning. We do not invent dialogue, scenes or viewing experiences, or present promotional claims as independent assessment.
Commercial independence
Payment cannot purchase a favorable critical judgment. Sponsored material, complimentary products and affiliate relationships must be disclosed where relevant. Paid placements must be distinguishable from independent editorial. We will not promise streams, sales, chart positions or reach we cannot substantiate.
Corrections
Send a correction request, article link and supporting evidence to margin.tone.editors@gmail.com. Material factual corrections should be identified on the article; disagreement with a critical opinion is not in itself a factual error.
Images, quotations and links
Use artwork and photographs only with an appropriate permission or other valid basis, retain credits, and keep quotations brief and purposeful. Links to outside services do not imply endorsement of every claim on those services.